Do Religious Beliefs Stifle Creativity?
Although I grew up in the Lutheran Church, in 1979 I converted to Seventh-day Adventism and became deeply rooted in its apocalyptic fervor. I have become so deeply involved in the faith that in less than a year I have flown across half of the United States to study for the ministry.
Before my conversion, during my teenage years, I had been a very creative person. I played drums and guitar, spent many hours sketching, wrote poetry, spent a royal ransom to buy a new Nikon camera and a wide-angle lens to take photos of skateboarders, and I was skating about 20 hours a week.
Then at nineteen I was “saved”, went to school to study for the ministry, and gave up all forms of creative “personal satisfaction” except for the guitar.
First, I gave up skating. Then the desire to keep the second commandment and “not to create cropped images” led me to sell my beloved camera. The drums were strictly verboten in my denomination, so i gave up the best instrument, which ironically helps other musicians keep time. And even though I kept my classical guitar, I had to reduce my playing to an elementary level so that my music could be accepted by other devotees.
The day the music died. “
I have no doubt that this creative death sentence made me cherish the Immortal Song American pie by Don McLean in which he sings. . .
“.. goodbye, Miss American Pie
I drove my Chevrolet to the dike, but the dike was dry
These good old boys drank whiskey and rye
Sing, “This will be the day I die
It will be the day that I die “
Why? Because I attribute my conversion to Christianity to “the day music died”. In other words, the period when creativity died in my life.
A little science
There isn’t a lot of scientific data on the subject, but what little evidence there is leans in the affirmative. Yes, unbelievers are more creative than believers. Here are a few sources that readers can browse to find out some interesting details such as. . .
There is some evidence to suggest that “apostates” were more likely to have participated in many creative simulations and role plays as children.
In another study, using gross national product per capita (GDPpc) in 87 countries as a guide, found:
“The results showed that: (1) religiosity was negatively associated with creativity at the national level; (2) The proportions of Protestant and Catholic adherents in a country were both positively associated with national creativity, while the proportion of adherents of Islam was negatively associated with national creativity. . . “
Science has a way of presenting data that is often dry and impersonal. In determining whether religion hinders or promotes a person’s creative talents, subjective experience may prove to be the best indicator.
What is your experience ?
In my personal experience, religion has killed my creative interests in the short term and probably reduced them in the long term. During my time as an Adventist, I acted on the imperative that Jesus could return at any time, so I did not have time (and other disciples of the faith) to engage in frivolous creative activities. The notable acceptance is that if one uses one’s “talents” to promote the tenets of the faith, then one’s creative aspirations are welcome.
Another point I want to emphasize is that once I left religion, I started to make up for lost time. I reverted vigorously to the creative interests I had before my conversion. I did it for personal pleasure but also to reconnect with people. Very little happens in life that does not rely on human creativity and ingenuity. If we don’t use our talents, we are dead to the world.
One might even conclude that a world filled with religious followers, who do not appreciate the creative progress made by mankind in the fields of science, is also dead.
So, I ask the question: Are skeptics, atheists and other non-believers more creative than people who follow religions?